While a simple outfit change might not seem all that newsworthy, longtime Yellowstone fans disagree. “I’m not typically critical of anything when it comes to these shows… So here’s my one and only critique: That suit did not get enough screen time in this episode… that is all,” one fan commented on photos from the episode on the official Dutton Ranch Instagram page. “Cole Hauser is one fine man. He made a lot of women fall in love with Rip Wheeler,” someone else chimed in. “When he stepped out in the suit! Rip Wheeler, the man that [you] are,” another fan ogled. “The hat is everything! The essence of him,” someone else commented with a praise emoji.

Of course, Beulah might have said it best. Upon seeing Rip and his family ride up (yes, ride up!) to the party on horseback, even she couldn’t help but double-take, claiming he looked, “Sharp enough to cut glass.”

Even if Rip’s suit was a one-and-done event in the series, there’s no doubt we’re about to get more jaw-dropping moments from him and Beth in the final two episodes of Season 1.

New episodes of Dutton Ranch air Fridays on Paramount+.