Luke Grimes, best known for his role as Kayce Dutton on Yellowstone, initially found himself shocked by the idea of a Yellowstone spin-off focused on his character. In a recent interview with Parade, Grimes admitted that when he first heard about the concept of a Kayce Dutton procedural show, he was far from impressed. He recalled thinking that it sounded like “a crazy idea” and “really terrible.” At the time, the actor had little interest in the idea, doubting its potential for success. However, his perspective would soon change after meeting with Spencer Hudnut, the showrunner behind Marshals.

When Grimes was first pitched the idea of Marshals, he couldn’t quite wrap his head around it. As a spin-off to the massive hit Yellowstone, the show was expected to explore Kayce Dutton’s life beyond the Dutton Ranch, this time as a member of an elite team of U.S. Marshals. The show would dive into his personal struggles, including dealing with the loss of his wife, Monica Dutton, and attempting to balance his duties as a father to his son, Tate. For Grimes, this sounded like a far cry from the thrilling drama of Yellowstone, where Kayce’s life seemed to be taking a much-needed break after a tumultuous journey.

Despite his reservations, Grimes gave the show a chance after speaking with Hudnut, who presented the concept in a way that piqued his interest. Hudnut explained that the show would have procedural elements but wouldn’t be a typical procedural show. “We want this to have a procedural element, but it’s sort of going to be this hybrid and kind of like no procedural you’ve seen before,” Hudnut explained to Grimes. Although the actor was skeptical, he became intrigued by the idea of a procedural with a twist. He admitted that while he’d heard similar promises before, Hudnut was, in fact, being truthful, and Marshals would ultimately take a different approach to the genre.

The procedural structure of Marshals may not have been what Grimes initially envisioned, but it still captured his attention. The show, while introducing individual cases in each episode, also weaves larger, multi-episode storylines that will span across multiple seasons. This approach provides a deeper connection to the characters and allows for more dramatic tension to unfold over time. Grimes described this structure as a “great device” for showcasing the missions the characters undertake while also providing the audience with a satisfying payoff at the end of each episode. The show, although not entirely free of flaws, has carved out a unique path that distinguishes it from traditional procedural dramas.

The decision to move forward with Marshals turned out to be the right one, at least in terms of its future. The show has already been renewed for a second season, indicating that it is performing well enough to secure additional episodes. However, despite the renewal, fan reactions have been mixed. Many viewers have expressed dissatisfaction with the show, noting that it doesn’t quite measure up to its predecessor. Some fans feel that Marshals carries the same core elements of Yellowstone but lacks the strong dialogue and engaging storylines that made the original show a hit. In fact, Grimes himself seems to share some of these sentiments, given how often he’s mentioned his initial skepticism about the project.

For Grimes, his doubts about the show have been well-documented. His reactions to several aspects of Marshals mirror what fans have expressed after seeing the first few episodes. From his initial shock over the procedural premise to his surprise at Monica’s untimely death, Grimes has been vocal about the challenges he faced in adapting to the show’s direction. These reservations likely reflect the broader confusion among fans, who expected Marshals to live up to the high standards set by Yellowstone but found the spin-off to be lacking in certain areas.

Even though Marshals may not be an instant success, there’s still hope for it to improve as the series progresses. The writers and producers are clearly trying to differentiate the show from Yellowstone, not just in terms of characters but also in its tone and narrative structure. The decision to kill off Monica Dutton, for example, was likely a move to ensure that Marshals would stand on its own and not feel like a mere extension of Yellowstone. Paramount’s efforts to separate the two shows, especially given their streaming deals, also reflect a desire to create something new without relying too heavily on the past. Yet, despite these efforts, Marshals still feels very much like Yellowstone with a few new characters, resulting in a show that lacks some of the original’s magic.

Ultimately, Grimes’ change of heart about Marshals serves as a reminder of how even seasoned actors can have doubts about new projects, especially when they don’t align with their initial expectations. While he was initially unsure about the show, his commitment to the role and his collaboration with Hudnut proved that sometimes, the best projects take time to grow into something special. Whether Marshals can evolve into a series as impactful as Yellowstone remains to be seen, but for now, fans will have to wait and see how the show develops in future episodes.